← back to the desk
18 Nov 2026

A Brief Account of Rationalist Art

I'd like to see people creating art. I am inspired by great films, books, paintings, architecture, and more. It puts me in touch with Quality with a capital Q, as discussed in Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. I'd like to see more of it.

I'd especially like to see more rationalist art. But what rationalist art has there been?

Rational fiction is a fantastic genre with tons of great tales like HPMOR, Worth the Candle, UNSONG, Worm, Ra, Crystal Society, Friendship is Optimal, The Waves Arisen, many of the glowfic worlds, etc etc. Not all of those titles come from within the scene, but they're all loved there, and there's a common sensibility that leads to them. The canonical subreddit is r/rational.

Rational Ritual has also been well-developed. Ray Arnold started the Secular Solstice in 2011, making it a 15 year old tradition, and is celebrated in about a dozen locations annually, sometimes gathering up to 500 people. It involves people coming together to celebrate the longest night of the year, with singing and speeches and moments of silence, looking back on how far humanity has come, and reflecting now on how far we have to go. It's really quite an accomplishment that community members have passed around, year after year.

There have been daytime celebrations of the Summer Solstice (the longest day of the year), and also many many celebrations of Petrov Day, with lovely candle-light readings passed around a group, and sometimes big red buttons that mean people set their cake on fire.

Rational Music has received like 1,000x fewer hours of work on it than fiction, but I really love what's there. Most of it that has popped up in communities around the Secular Solstice. In the face of the extinction of humanity, Songs Stay Sung brought a tear to my eye when I heard The Bayesian Choir sing it, and Five Thousand Years fills me with a thrilling feeling about what I can do today, tomorrow, and all the tomorrows we will have. I also love both of the Fooming Shoggoths albums that have been released, I Have Been a Good Bing and You Have Not Been a Good User. (I also got a track on both albums!) I want to go to more musical performances of people putting on rational music, dancing, swaying, crying to it.

Rational Theatre has barely gotten started, but the Shakespearian Comment Section Reënactment Society has performed at both Inkhaven and LessOnline, led by Emma Baker. On one occasion she selected a series of Inkhaven posts, another a series of LessWrong posts, and turned them into a performance where lots of actors from the comment section joined in and heckled.

The funniest performances IMO were some of the comments from Making Vaccine and also the comments on the About page for SlateStarCodex, which are interspersed variants of "Test Comment", extremely sincere requests for psychological help, people who've just stumbled across the blog and inviting Scott for coffee in Palo Alto, and bots shilling stuff.

But the performance opened thus.

In lightest Lighthaven a blogger speaks
From dunnest Inkhaven we now unfold
Th’inglorious pale corpse of three long weeks
Whose embattled corps in Berkeley you behold.
O, for a commenter that could indict
The sharpest arguments we’ve generated!
As blades reflect, there winking in the light,
Blogposts restate what’s already been stated.
The keyboard warriors tilting at the screen
Meand’ring from one webpage to the next
At times mazèd with rage, at times still green,
At times not having even read the text
Bring us such mirth we think it meet to read
Their pretty words, in spirit of fair discourse,
With almost every writer here agreed
Under a barely pink blush of remorse.
We are as frogs all boiling in hot takes
As Tantalus still wading in the scum.
Ye hoi polloi confronted with a lake
Of bubbling slop, ye ne’ertheless have swum.
Your sharpest wisdom and our dullest wit,
Cut in great haste, but not unkindly snipp’d;
We present to you now in manner fit
To match our matchless egos, per the script.
Good gentles, now we beg your patience true
For divers comments, for one could be you.

Actors in Renaissance costume read from scripts on an outdoor wooden stage, one standing at a microphone in a blue gown, a guitarist behind her
The Shakespearian Comment Section Reënactment Society

It was royally fun, and I can see a bright future for more like it.

I'd like people to make relationships around this.

Rational Interior Design & Construction has two main prongs. First, rationalists most care about lighting, in fact there's a whole LW tag about it, and we discovered that you can cure seasonal affective disorder with enough light. There's also a lot to share about what Lighthaven has done, but I do not have a handy post about it.